Pile of crap A:

Pile of Crap B:

So the question is who’s pile of crap makes you wince more? Pile A or Pile B.  Vote on the right sidebar. The winner gets both piles of crap.  Please only one vote per person, contest ends Sunday 2/20/11.

So the winner is Pile of Crap B.  I am in the process of setting up a new Battle of Crap and have one participant.  If you want in, let me know ASAP.


28 responses »

  1. Kris says:

    Are we allowed to enter our expired redemptions of Philip Humber?

    • chemgod says:

      Kris, that is a fantastic question! Although to be honest an actual redeemed Humber would be worth more than an expired redemption card. I think we should go no to that question.

  2. Samuel Pair says:

    Did you get the e-mail with my scan?

  3. Bill says:

    At least I knew all of the names in the first pile…

  4. chemgod says:

    not to influence the voting but think about the hit compared to the price of the product.

  5. Teddy Dziuba says:

    Definitely pile A. The money the Mets invested in Humber has made them gun-shy to pull the trigger on big money draft picks ever since.

  6. Mike D says:

    I would think that pile B is a bigger pile of crap. Regardless of the inadequacy of the two piles of steamers, I can’t help but like the Sweet Spot autos no matter who signed them. So that holds a little more weight and I know someone who actually would like that Richie Sexson card!

  7. HOODLUM says:

    Pile B FTW

  8. Nathan says:

    Pile A is FAR worse IMO.

    Pile B features a Bazooka card, which is a bit goofy but intentionally so and a 206 auto, which aside from the big shiny sticker is actually a very nice design.

  9. DanMan says:

    Both are pretty crappy but B has nicer looking cards. So I’ll go with A.

  10. hamrammobtown says:

    Crappity crap crap, but pile B wins, since pile A is a more notable group of suck.

  11. CK says:

    I like the Bazooka card, so I’d say Pile A is worse.

  12. BP20Sandman says:

    Pile B is definitely worse to me – the Sweet Spot autos are still pretty cool!

  13. polishgooner says:

    Pile B is worse at least I heard of all of the players in Pile A. In Pile B I heard of no one.

  14. mike rinaldi says:

    Pile B is Worse.

  15. Robert Costa says:

    Pile B because whenever there is a cut of I guy I never heard of it’s never good.

  16. Jason Christopherson says:

    I’d have to say Pile B is the crappier of the crap, but only because I’m a Brewer fan.

  17. Tom Seaver says:

    Pile A is worse. Anything with Phillip Humber takes the cake but when you add that horrible Bando card, it’s unbeatable!

  18. James says:

    Pile B is garbage of all because none of the players I have never heard of. Pile A have pretty neat cards like the sweet spot and the fleer with a ticket autoed.

  19. Mike Binger says:

    Pile A . I hate that Tristar cuts up photos to create cards.

  20. todduncommon says:

    Pile A takes it for me. The Sexson is a push with the Snyder in group B. The Humber pushes with the Paulino, and the Kwame and the Solano (who?) are a push.

    That Sal Bando franken-cut, though is a pile of crap by itself that just overwhelms all other cards in both groups. What is to be gained by ruining an autograph picture in order to create an ugly card? Is Bando’s autograph that desirable or rare? We know the answer is no. The only ones that got value out of that is Tristar, who put that dog in a wrapper and had the audacity to consider that a box “hit”, and it sold to some poor schlub looking for a HOFer.

    The Bubba tries super hard to sink group B to the level that Sal sinks group A, but it just really can’t compete. It does try hard however. I mean, does anybody actually collect anything from Just? On purpose?

  21. Cameron says:

    That Kwame auto is swell.

  22. cubsfan731 says:

    Pile A, for sure. I’ve never winced like I did when I saw the Sexson card. Now I know pain.

  23. Brendan says:

    I’d go with Crap Pile A. The Sexson patch is decent.

  24. Hackenbush says:

    Pile A is worse because of the Bando travesty.

  25. Philsphan3 says:

    Pile A. Kwame Brown? That settles it right there.

  26. csd7227 says:

    Pile A is worse because of the Sal Bando card. It looks as though their printing press was broken, but I am sure that was intended.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s